Extreme Makeover; Moline Illinois Edition

By Art Goodrich
After watching the Moline budget talks being covered on local TV, in the local papers and listening on local talk radio, I am convinced that fire departments will NEVER win another battle against manpower cuts, as long as they insist on using the "more people will die" strategy.

And it's not because it isn't true, but it's because it is no longer getting the attention of the majority of their cities' residents. In today's selfish society, people don't care, as long as THEY aren't the ones dying.

It's the ones USING the service that is driving up cost for the rest of us, some will say.

Did you know that there are people in Tennessee who won't pay a lousy 75 bucks a year for fire protection, but will complain to the national news outlets when they don't get FREE service if their domicile catches fire?

It's true.

I thought that the area firefighters, supporters and particularly the firefighter union did a fantastic job of getting the information out. They didn't go overboard with the "more will die" message, but they mentioned it. What struck me was that when many mentioned the additional risk it would put on the firefighters, there was a palpable indifference by some on the city council. It was as if they were sitting there believing that taking such risks was a part of a Moline firefighter's job description and it is...to a point. Cutting manpower and pushing the risk to those who remain is NOT acceptable risk and shame on the Moline city council if this is what they believe.

The city administrator wants the residents to believe that it is about the high cost of firefighter pensions. That's rubbish; something that they are willing to pay more for in regards to its removal.

"Special risk" pension plans were designed for two reasons: firefighters and cops. Benefits were enhanced to balance against a lower wage and it was thought at the time that people who rush into burning buildings and people who are shot at should receive compensation for the risks that they took to provide for the public's safety. To that, I say "AMEN".

The early retirement clauses were inserted, because of the many hazards bombarding public safety employees; both physical and mental.

So; what happened?

Well, from where I sit; the other unions representing non-public safety employees were lobbying the lawmakers in their states to include THEIR union members in the "special risk" plans, causing the pension payments to soar. It comes at a time when we are seeing "special risk" retirees going up and general pensioners' numbers decreasing. Again; this is my observation.

In addition; while the firefighters in my state were dutifully contributing their 9.5 percent into the pension plan, cities were deferring and delaying their share.

I swear; if the city "bosses"-i.e. city councils-ran businesses like they do their cities, they would have been sent packing before they even got their probationary periods served!

The role of government, first and foremost, is to provide for the public's safety. Everything after THAT should be on the table for debate.

As I look at my future retirement in the private sector, I wonder what is a fair retirement for public servants?

Look at Social Security. It has been said that public servants will not get Social Security, but I know of several firefighters who have "side jobs" or "side businesses" and unless it is a strictly cash basis, I would believe that they would be paying into Social Security.

And if they are paying into Social Security, then wouldn't seem likely that they could draw on it at some point? Or maybe, I am wrong.

In my case, when I become eligible for Social Security, it will be approximately at 20 percent of what I now make. But, if they keep raising the eligibility age, I might get ZERO percent, as I might be dead before I ever collect a dime.

My 401K might give me another couple hundred bucks a month, but then, there might be a rule by then, forcing a reduction in my Social Security or it will be taxed down to where I might have enough left to pay for a newspaper subscription.

Public pensions at 85 percent; it that too much and if so, then what IS fair? 80? 70? 50? I really don't know, because I have been raised to get what I can.

We need to keep in mind that the value of a pension in a union contract has been negotiated in a fair collective bargaining process.

Public safety employees did not hold a gun to city government's head nor did they hold communities hostage. They continued to answer the call to every incident in good times and bad.

And yet, in today's climate; firefighters are being blamed for budget shortfalls.

THAT isn't fair!

I don't know what is left to argue. When fire departments have proven their value to the quality of life in their communities; when they have been repeatedly hailed as heroes, you have to wonder why they, along with their communities are being fed this poison pill by city leaders, who find creative ways to waste millions of dollars in order to sacrifice the public's safety and again, I say what is more important than the public's safety?

In a calling that is steeped in grand history and tradition; firefighters will have to look towards non-traditional ways to preserve their jobs and the public's safety in their communities.

It should start NOW!

 The opinions and views expressed are those of the article's author, Art Goodrich, who also writes as ChiefReason. They do not reflect the opinions and views of www.fireengineering.com , Fire Engineering Magazine, PennWell Corporation or his dog, Chopper. This article is protected by federal copyright laws and cannot be re-produced in any form.

Previous Posts

Trustees; Train Hard or Go Home!

Thu Apr 05 19:59:00 CDT 2012

Firefighters in Dresses Hailed as Heroes?

Wed Mar 21 19:41:00 CDT 2012

Rescuing the Lady

Mon Mar 05 18:33:00 CST 2012

Take a Bow, Bowring!

Mon Feb 27 18:49:00 CST 2012

The Love of the...Stress?

Sun Feb 05 10:11:00 CST 2012

Blogging Then and Now

Mon Jan 30 19:44:00 CST 2012

What Are Your Plans For 2012?

Wed Dec 28 16:27:00 CST 2011

Christmas and the Six Year Old

Tue Dec 20 18:19:00 CST 2011

Extreme Makeover; Moline Illinois Edition

Thu Dec 15 20:11:00 CST 2011

Anatomy of a Firefighter

Sun Dec 04 15:34:00 CST 2011

ChiefReason for Dummies

Sat Nov 26 17:39:00 CST 2011

I Punted; Super Committee Fumbles!

Mon Nov 21 18:48:00 CST 2011

Ohio; Community Organizing-Platinum Edition

Sun Nov 13 10:32:00 CST 2011

Private Sacrifice

Tue Nov 08 05:52:00 CST 2011

Lit Fires; Light Sentences

Tue Nov 01 07:39:00 CDT 2011

ChiefReason’s 2011 Halloween Spooktickle

Sun Oct 30 20:15:00 CDT 2011

City Fires; Chief “Retires”

Mon Oct 24 20:08:00 CDT 2011

May I Demonstrate?

Thu Oct 20 17:41:00 CDT 2011

Kansas City Was a Ghost Town

Mon Oct 10 20:58:00 CDT 2011

Our Incivility Ability

Tue Oct 04 20:41:00 CDT 2011

Remembering Bradley Golden – Now Ten Years Gone

Thu Sep 22 20:15:00 CDT 2011

Paul Krugman: Biggest Loser is a Nobel Winner?

Fri Sep 16 17:43:00 CDT 2011

Never Forgetting is to Always Remember

Tue Sep 06 18:20:00 CDT 2011

While America Slept, Lady Liberty Wept

Tue Sep 06 18:12:00 CDT 2011

Sudden Separation

Tue Aug 16 20:17:00 CDT 2011