OVERHAUL AND SALVAGE… IN THEORY AND PRACTICE

OVERHAUL AND SALVAGE… IN THEORY AND PRACTICE

By

One of the 20 pumpers dispatched by the New York Fire Department to Danbury, Conn., during costly 1955 flood, getting set to operate eductor in the extensive flood dewatering operations in that city after flood waters had subsided —Photo courtesy Tom Magner

PART XII

Removing Water from Buildings— Dewatering Basements Presents Problems

THIS CHAPTER is a continuation of Part XI in which emphasis was placed on removing water from areas below the fire, but not from basement or cellar. In this article we discuss the problem of dewatering those belowground-level areas with some consideration also, of the part played by elevators and elevator shafts.

The reader is urged to bear in mind the general recommendations on removal of water from buildings contained in the preceding chapter, in his consideration of the following.

Actually, it does not matter how the water came to accumulate in the basement or sub-basement of a building, whether as a result of fire extinguishing operations carried on above ground level or in the sub-surface levels, or sprinkler failure. The main problem is one of dewatering the accumulated deposits.

True, where fire is fought above ground floor, some salvage operations of a flood-preventive nature can be carried out in the sub-surface areas where conditions make the maneuvers safe for the salvage personnel. Safety of life in any and all salvage operations comes ahead of saving of property. But in general, whenever any large scale fire extinguishing operations are undertaken, it is quite conceivable that water may accumulate in sub-surface areas faster than approved salvage dewatering operations can remove it, or prevent its entry into the areas.

Where personnel, because of hazardous conditions, are unable to operate in these areas, and open drains or otherwise prepare to forestall excess water accumulations, it is a foregone conclusion that water removal will be a major operation. This supports the contention advanced in the preceding chapter than under any and all conditions, dewatering operations should begin at the earliest possible moment, even if such operations are only of a preventive or precautionary nature, in anticipation of possible large scale water accumulation in these belowsurface levels. This presupposes, of course, that the fire is so located that salvagemen can enter the basement or cellar to (a) determine the equipment and/or stocks that may be damaged by water deposits; (b) shift or remove such of those stocks as may be possible; (c) prepare drains or other outlets to carry off the possible deposits.

Fig. 1. Use of pumps from street level through sidewalk grates (A) or down available stairways (B). This method is advocoted when conditions render entry into basement area unsafe. Suction taken in pits at lower points. Use strainersFig. 2. Pumping out basement from one or more points. At times it is impossible to locate pumps directly in front of building. It then becomes necessary to conduct pumping operations at secondary entries, such as windows as shown (B) and any available surface openings (A)Fig. 3. Eductors are employed when excessive amounts of water deposits are encountered. Eductor is preferable to direct suction to avoid damage to pumpers from debris or grit in water. (A) is the line from pumper, (B) 4-inch hard suction line and (C) the eductorFig. 4. Pumping of sub-level surface where pumps are located well within basement area. Long discharge lines can be avoided by utilizing sewer lines (A) and (B). Remove cleanout caps and insert discharge line into same. Caution must be used to avoid carbon monoxide fumes from gas driven pumps wherever used inside buildingFig. 5. Method for pumping out sub-basement, again using sewer cleanout caps. When this method cannot be used, it is necessary to pump in series

Sub-surface fire salvage problems

Where the fire has originated in the basement or sub-basement areas, two salvage situations may arise. Either the fire has extended through-out the entire basement area or (2) the fire is confined to one portion of the basement.

When the fire has extended throughout the entire area, or the nature of the fire wherever it is makes the basement unsafe for operating personnel, salvage is generally confined to control of water that may be penetrating through walls into adjoining basement properties.

Control of such water may be possible by using stock covers as blocks and runways to confine and direct the water to available drains or other outlets. Either that, or pumping operations may be necessary if no drainage facilities are present.

Breaching basement walls may be called for

When conditions are favorable, it is sometimes advantageous to breach cellar walls at a point where the water can easily be directed to drains, or pumped out of the building. This method is particularly effective when the penetration of water through walls is taking place at a number of points.

Regardless of these measures, as soon as conditions permit, entry should be made into the fire building and the removal of water started immediately.

When fire is confined to one portion of the basement and conditions permit entry of personnel, the first action should be to hold the water to the smallest area possible by the use of covers as door blocks, and/or the flow of water should be directed to available drainage avenues, using covers as runways. Should the overall depth of water in an area call for it (and drainage facilities be inadequate for the task of dewatering), removal of water should be augmented by pumping.

A word or two about drainage. Few basements are without drains of some sort, either that, or they have the means for improvising drains, i.e., waste pipes, etc.

The breaking of waste pipes may be necessary, even though the basement is equipped with floor drains, and sump pumps are utilized at lowpoints.

Floor drains are often covered with stock, making them useless or the holes in the drain plates may be plugged with debris so as to render them insufficient to carry off the water rapidly enough.

Sump pumps are rarely of sufficient power and capacity to rid basements of heavy water accumulations fast enough and they eventually become inundated, or clogged with debris and thus become inoperative. Also, any power-operated sump pump or other type water mover may be deactivated by a power shutdown or failure.

It is general practice among insurance fire patrols when fire has reached serious proportions (usually indicated by multiple alarms), and the quantities of water that are, or will be, employed for the extinguishing process are beyond control, to attempt to locate and rupture if advisable, all waste pipe lines. When this is done, strainers should be inserted in openings to insure that debris will not clog lines.

Where conditions make it possible, and safe, efforts should be made to locate pits that are readily available for the insertion of suction lines at street level. Locating such deep points may be a tricky and dangerous business and considerable care should be exercised in such search. If building owners or occupants can be induced to indicate by placards or signs on nearby walls or posts where such pits and/or drains are located, it can be materially beneficial in helping locate them under water.

All water main supply lines, if possible, should be shut down to avoid any prolonged water discharge from broken or ruptured pipes. Also, electrical equipment in the areas, which might be damaged by water should be de-energized. Main switches, however, should not be pulled until and unless the fire forces operating above are notified.

Points for dewatering sub-surfaces

Briefly, here are the more important means of dewatering sub-surface areas such as basements and sub-basements (in addition to the use of exterior or above-ground pumps, eductors, etc.):

  1. Built in floor drains.
  2. Waste and soil pipes (connected with washstands, toilets, etc.)
  3. Connections or openings with adjoining properties (through which excess water may be drained or pumped and thence conveyed to safe points)

Special pump unit

The New York Fire Patrol has a special mobile unit which carries a variety of pumps capable of dewatering buildings, even under the most adverse conditions. Included are the following:

(At 6-foot lift) Two 120 gpm gas pumps

(At 12-foot lift) Two 60 gpm electrical driven submerged pumps

(At 6-foot lift) Four 20 gpm portable electrical driven pumps

(4 to 1, at 10

foot lift) Two eductors

(N. Y. Fire Department pumpers are employed to operate these devices) One 500 gpm pump, mounted on a trailer, which is used to supply eductors or for taking direct suction.

The Unit also carries gas-driven generator for supplying power to electrical driven pumps, and a variety of tools designed to assist in water removal.

Elevator shafts bane or blessing?

In the first part of this chapter we said that water finds its level. In so doing it takes the paths of least resistance. which are usually the vertical arteries, such as stairways and shaftways.

If these arteries or channels for the overflow can be dammed or otherwise blocked to detour the water away from, or out of these channels, and out of the building, or into areas where there is least possibility of water damage, this procedure is recommended. As was pointed out in the case of stairways, this method of shifting the channel by bagging or other means can often be done, but it is not so easy of accomplishment where the vertical artery is an elevator shaft. That is why it was recommended that where possible, waste water should be bagged or dammed on floors or diverted, and if necessary, chuted away from shafts.

At their best, elevator shafts are not the most desirable avenues for relieving floors of surplus water. Even though the most elaborate precautions are taken, and the elevators are rendered inoperable during operations, the possibility of water damage, through its finding its gravity level is always present. It appears to be the unanimous agreement among professional salvagemen that employment of elevator shafts to dewater upper floors of a structure should be done only where absolutely necessary. phase of salvage and should be given considerable thought. Basements are frequently the central location of the source of power need by occupants of a building in order to keep them in business.

Continued on page 326

Fig. 6. Sewer line trap, showing points where salvagemen may remove caps on line, according to prevailing conditions at time of fire: (A) preferable point (remove or break cap); (B) secondary point (remove or break cap); (C) last resort, to facilitate water removal when conditions do not allow personnel to remain in basement for prolonged period. Strainers must be usedFig. 7. After pumping operations, low pockets of water can be emptied by drilling holes through concrete floors: (A), first penetration—pin removed; (B) second hole to be placed 8 to 12 inches from first hole

SALVAGE AND OVERHAUL Continued from page 323

Nevertheless, it is agreed that every effort should be put forth to afford all possible protection to elevators. They are the first line of transportation at lofty fires and may be the means of saving fire fighters and salvagemen exhausting, back-breaking climbing up numerous flights of stairs and quite possibly rendering them incapable of performing any work upon arrival at the fire or water accumulation.

It may be considered a foregone conclusion that where basements exist and elevators serve below street levels, there are storages and/or machinery susceptible to water damage. The basement, therefore, is one of the first considerations to have the attention of the salvageman.

Value of pre-fire Inspections

Pre-fire inspection should acquaint the fire department, and it is to be hoped, the salvage corps, with the contents of basements; whether or not costly elevator or other machinery, heating and lighting equipment, as well as storages are located there. And at the same time, such advanced investigating should disclose the most available and advantageous means of removing accumulated basement water deposits. The more valuable and destructible the storages and other material located in below ground levels, the more important it is to chart beforehand the various outlets for dewatering and the methods that may have to be employed in the operation. And knowing the vertical arteries of all kinds is a requisite.

Dewatering operations for salvage purposes are not necessarily related to fire or its aftermath. Water damage, or threat of it, may arise from a sprinkler leak or breakdown, or from flood. For the most part, however, salvagemen are concerned with removal of surplus water resulting from fire extinguishment.

The source of the excess water to be removed, by one means or another, suggests to the experienced salvagemen the possible damage that it may do to stocks and building and also, the safest and best way to remove it.

Water that has drained through fire damaged materials carries with it debris of different kinds. This may be cinders and ash, damaged stock, even chemicals. In general, such accumulations result in “dirty,” if not dangerous water.

By contrast, water from a damaged or broken sprinkler system may be said to be “clean” water. Its foreign matter content will depend largely upon the kind of storage in the flooded area. Dewatering of this accumulation, therefore, is a cleaner, easier, safer job both for men and equipment, then ridding a fire building of its accumulated dirt and debris.

Water from nature’s floods is invariably foul and muddy and quite likely will contain grit, refuse and foreign matter mixed with the residue of the materials which it involves in basement or otherwise.

For the most part, dewatering operations involve removal of water, generally foul, from basements or subsurface area, and all possible precautions should be taken to see that the least possible damage is done to dewatering facilities.

Conclusions on basement dewatering

Removal of water from basements is a serious and possibly dangerous,

Continued on page 348

SALVAGE

Continued from page 326

Basements usually contain the main electrical power supply which, if interrupted, can causa complete shutdown of operation.

They are also the location of heating facilities which, if impaired, may have far-reaching effect on the ability of the concerns or residents occupying the structure to continue operations. Lack of heat makes the building unfit for human occupancy during the heating season. It permits freezing of water pipes, sprinkler systems and storage tanks. It has adverse effects on goods which cannot be subjected to low temperatures, but which are often stored in basements. And lack of heat to dry out a building usually results in excessive warping and possible formation of ice within the structure which later melts to cause unexpected and unnecessary damage.

Also subject to damage through basement flooding are refrigeration systems, particularly motors and compressors. Salvage operational reports indicate that interruption of refrigeration in certain occupancies has caused damage in excess of actual fire losses.

Mention has previously been made of elevator motors and equipment. The loss of transportation in a sizable building can not only seriously hamper fire fighters and salvagement but it can cause costly delays to the occupants.

Storage is indigenous with basements. Many below-surface areas in modern structures have large storage facilities, the contents of which would suffer extensive damage if water control in these sub surface areas was neglected.

A final detail is exposures. The fire forces may keep a fire from entering adjoining buildings above the street level, but if water is allowed to accumulate and reach excessive heights in basements, it will penetrate through walls and partitions quite possibly causing severe damage to the contents and facilities of adjoining occupancies.

The excellent diagrams used in this chapter are the work of Sgt. George Post, of the New York Fire Patrol.

OVERHAUL AND SALVAGE… IN THEORY AND PRACTICE

OVERHAUL AND SALVAGE… IN THEORY AND PRACTICE

Dewatering can be a problem as in this chemical fire. Not all this water passed through the chemical warehouse during fire extinguishing operations but enough did—and picked up chemicals en route to produce the effect shown. Water damage in this blaze was reported greater than actual fire losses. Salvagemen working inside took considerable punishment from water— hot, cold and chemical-laden

PART XI

Removing Water From Buildings

INASMUCH AS WATER causes more damage than the fire itself in most fire control and extinguishing operations of any magnitude, the problems of preventing the extension of water into and involvement of perishable materials, and speeding the removal of water from building and contents are paramount.

The majority of salvage operations hinge upon these factors. For the purpose of this study we will refer to this procedure as dewatering.

The methods and techniques of dewatering as related to salvage, whether the property is involved in fire, flood, or for some other reason, will be reviewed in detail in subsequent chapters. At this time it is in order to discuss certain general fundamentals leading up to the actual dewatering operations themselves. Emphasis is placed on removing water below the fire, but not from basement or cellar. This phase will be covered later.

Physical Aspects and Size-up

Throughout this series we have repeatedly referred to the importance of size-up in planning and executing salvage operations.

It is essential in mapping out dewatering operations that certain physical aspects of building and occupancy —and exposures—be known. Pre-fire knowledge of the occupancy in question, as previously recommended, will greatly facilitate dewatering and other salvage operations during and after the fire, once it occurs.

These physical aspects involve

  1. The building itself: construction, combustibility, etc.
  2. The type of occupancy: susceptibility to damage by fire, water, smoke
  3. The location of the building: with relation to approaches, exposures, etc.
  4. The location of the fire: with respect to heighth and location in the building, involvement, exposures, etc.
  5. The position of the fire with respect to the floors, floor area and other details that might be involved in dewatering.

It is common knowledge that water seeks its level. It will find the tiniest openings to reach that level. It will penetrate and filter through what may appear to be the most impenetrable material, given the time. It will spread on some surfaces with almost unbelievable rapidity, particularly where there is a grade and it is on non-absorbable material.

Two factors to be noted in connection with ridding a building of water are: (1) the area and porosity of floors; and (2) area and type of ceilings present. Water can collect and spread out over wide areas in some ceilings as well as on floors. Worse still, the accumulation of water in ceiling spaces (the water may be scalding hot) constitutes a hazard not only to the materials and stocks below, but to those engaged in salvage and overhaul operations.

At the same time, size-up should pay particular attention to the occupancy itself, the kind and quantity of contents and a quick estimate of the risks involved should be made. Most experienced salvagemen can quickly estimate the value of such contents.

At the Top, But Below the Fire

Salvage operations, and we include dewatering, usually begin on the fire floor if possible and, if not, on the floor or floors below the fire—except of course where the fire is on the ground floor or below ground level. In any case, operations should begin as quickly as possible.

Sometimes floors con be opened up to drain into catch-alls or dams on floors below which, in turn chute or funnel the water out of the occupancy. Such was the case in this Chicago building where water is being collected in a catch-all contrived of salvage covers to be chuted outside, from the floor below

—Photo courtesy Chicago Fire Insurance Patrol

Basically, these operations have two major objectives: (1) to protect the contents against the encroachment of water and (2) to contain and discharge the water insofar as possible outside the premises, so as to prevent further involvement and damage.

Salvage is performed below the fire floor by spreading and bagging covers. The severity of the fire and the extinguishing methods employed by the fire department will give some indication of the water problem to be faced, and the dewatering measures to be taken to cope with it.

Containing the water on the floor below the fire may be difficult, depending upon the area of involvement, the availability of salvagemen and equipment, and the conditions (heat and smoke) under which men have to work.

Every minute water remained on the floors of this high value occupancy, the New York News, it threatened to damage costly equipment and delay publication. New York Fire Patrolmen, using every known salvage device, and some they extemporized for the situation, worked water off floors, out of recesses and pits in one of the outstanding salvage operations of the day

It may be necessary to cut holes through flooring at the heaviest concentrations of water and to drain the discharge into chutes or funnels, thence out of doors, or down shafts. If the water can be bagged or dammed, it may be removed by mechanical means, such as shallow draft electric pumps, etc. Modern practice still relies heavily upon good old sawdust to dam and/or divert water to the point of discharge where its exit will do the least harm.

The type of floor (construction and finish) may give an idea of the speed with which water may penetrate it and reach areas below. So too, will the number and kind of floor openings, pipe recesses, electrical fixtures and so on. Stairways and fire towers may become natural waterways when the water volume permits their use. Of course, where they are used, every effort should be made to block off doors and other openings so that the water will follow the most natural line of least resistance to its final exit.

Where possible, the ideal practice is to chute or otherwise divert the water out of the building via windows or other openings as nearly below the fire as possible, rather than to attempt to divert it down elevator shafts. Logically, the less water that is allowed to accumulate in the basement or on ground floor levels, the less post-fire dewatering will have to be done. As we shall see in the discussion of dewatering basements (in a later Chapter), every effort should be made to prevent water from entering basements either from the interior of the building or its exterior. Sometimes basement windows are recessed and water chuted or otherwise discharged from above into the open air, may find its way back into the structure.

Start Water Removal Immediately

Prompt action is essential in all salvage operations—particularly so in dewatering. Water removal should begin as quickly as possible. We have said that chutes or funnels should be used to divert heavy concentrations of water. There are plenty of small portable pumps and siphons that may be used to draft water from containers (the practice of scooping or shoveling out shallow water from bagged covers or other containers is being discontinued). Water so picked up can be discharged out of windows or into sinks or toilet bowls.

Attention should be given the ceiling below the fire floor because this is most likely to accumulate quantities of water and to possibly collapse on the heads of salvagemen or fire fighters. It may be advisable to puncture the ceiling to prevent collapse, and to drain off its contents into selected channels. Pendant light fixtures may be a path of discharge to floors below and should be checked.

It takes time and effort to set the stage for efficient below-fire salvage and dewatering at “working fires”, even with full crews of trained men. The longer the delay in getting to work, the more complicated and difficult the dewatering operation. A factor in speed, or the lack of it, is equipment. Lacking the essentials of covers, poles or such simple things as hammer and nails for example, may spell all the difference between effective and ineffective salvage dewatering.

Continued on page 230

OVERHAUL AND SALVAGE—Continued from page 219

As soon as practicable, salvage units should enter the fire floor to begin dewatering and other salvage operations at that level. If the necessary steps have been taken to direct water out of the building from the floor or floors below the fire, and the addition of water from the fire floor will not overburden, or flood the dewatering facilities, it may be advisable to cut suitable openings in the fire floor to direct the discharge to those facilities below. However, if the water on the fire floor can be discharged directly out of the structure from that floor, this is preferable.

Rapid removal of trapped water on floors and from ceilings is important if for no other reason than to avert prolonged dripping which will require leaving covers in place longer than should be necessary.

The author has made no attempt to discuss dewatering of small, average, fires such as occur in households, in which little water is used in extinguishing operations. Usually employment of sponges, squeegees, mops and rags will suffice to remove this water content. Further data on dewatering will be included in the succeeding chapters on basement dewatering and salvage operations relating to various individual occupancies.

Acknowledgement: The author gratefully acknowledges the assistance of Chief Joseph Scanlon, Superintendent, and Sergeant George Post, of the New York Fire Patrol in the preparation of this Chapter.